#307 – Dawn of Peacemakers [Spoiler-Free]

Box

Base price: ~$100?
1 – 4 players.
Play time: 30 minutes – 2 hours+. Depends on the scenario.
BGG Link

Buy directly!
Logged plays: 4 

Full disclosure: A review copy of Dawn of Peacemakers was provided by Snowdale Design.

Editor’s Note: This review is focused on the Campaign Mode. Skirmish Mode is not covered. Also, this is free of spoilers for the campaign, but by virtue of explaining how the campaign works this will cover the first game (without spoiling the ending). 

So, there are still some games that are pretty tough for me to get reviewed, and I’ve talked about them before. Basically any game with a lengthy story component, any legacy game, or any game you can only play once. Thankfully, since I’ve already reviewed Holding On, I got through a review of Charterstone, and I’m starting to (hopefully) get okay at reviewing the EXIT games, I think I am starting to figure out how I can write about things that weren’t previously in my wheelhouse. One such thing is Dawn of Peacemakers, the latest game from Snowdale Design. It’s a huge box with lots of minis and a lengthy story, but I love the Dale of Merchants series a lot (and it’s set in that universe) so I figured I might as well give it a shot.

In Dawn of Peacemakers, you’ve just gotten an urgent letter from a famous adventurer with bad news: war is about to break out between the macaws and the ocelots, and that will plunge the entire continent into chaos. If you act stealthily, you may be able to step in between both armies and convince them to settle down, but you’ll need to make sure you’re at almost every major conflict to manage these tensions before they escalate out of control. You may have some allies in this fight, but it won’t be easy; can you prevent a war?

Contents

Setup

Setup is fairly scenario-specific, so I’ll outline what happens in the first one. First, choose an Adventurer:

Adventurers

Each one has a letter written specifically for them; open one and read it!

Letters

Now, set out the board:

Board

You won’t need the other side; I don’t know when you will, but it’s there:

Other Side Board

You’ll need to set the tiles on the board:

Tiles

They follow a specific configuration; check the Campaign Book for those details:

Campaign Booklet

You’ll also want to set out the Unit Boards for each side:

Motivation Boards

And the Unit Cards. You’ll only be using these units, in this game:

Units

The campaign booklet will tell you which minis to grab:

Minis

And which bottoms to put on them:

Bottoms

Put them on their spaces, and add the Adventurers to the Start Space. You’ll also want to set up each Army’s Decks. Each Army has two decks: Ploys and Tasks. Both armies have the same Tasks:

Task Cards

But which tasks are in play is dictated by the Campaign Book. You’ll always use the same Ploys:

This slideshow requires JavaScript.

But each army has different ones. That’s always fun. The Campaign Book will also tell you how to align each army’s direction marker:

Direction Markers

That’s all you should need from that on setup. Shuffle the Resource Cards and deal each player 2:

Resource Cards

Speaking of resources, set the damage tokens aside:

Damage Tokens

Along with the Fortification Tokens:

Fortification Tokens

And the die:

Die

Once you’ve done that, you’re about ready to start! Give one player the Start Player Token (the other one is just a bonus):

Start Player Token

And yeah, you’re good to go for the first scenario!

Setup

Gameplay

Gameplay 1

So, in Dawn of Peacemakers, generally you’re trying to fulfill one scenario: you need to get both sides’ Motivation to drop below 2. When that happens, each side is ready to withdraw, and only a simultaneous cessation of hostilities is considered a victory for you. If you mess up and either side hits 0, they surrender, and you lose. It is unlikely but possible for you to somehow have both armies surrender to each other simultaneously, which is … still a loss, but a more baffling one.

This particular battle focuses on the Macaw advance across the local river. Each side starts on opposite sides of the river and you start in the center. The game is played over multiple rounds, each with several phases: the Adventurer Phase, Army Phase, and Status Phase. I’ll describe each in more detail.

Adventurer Phase

This is where your turns come in. You can perform actions to try and manipulate the armies from both sides in order to swing a more favorable outcome. Sometimes you don’t want to do anything — if you pass your turn, you may discard 1 Resource Card to draw a new one.

All the cards have multiple actions on them, indicated by the card, movement, and fortification icons along with the text. You may only resolve one of those things per card, and then it gets discarded. Naturally, if during the resolution you find that you’ve drawn a Task Card from one of the armies’ decks for a group without any units in play, remove it from the game and draw a new Task Card.

Anyways, let’s talk about each of the actions you can do:

  • Influence: This action allows you to reorder armies’ Task and Ploy cards to better suit your designs. When you use this action, you may look at cards for the army with a unit on the same location as you (referred to as your companion unit). When you decide to do this, you may ask your allies to also discard cards with card icons on them; you may take the number of cards from the Task or Ploy deck pictured on the discarded cards. Once everyone decides to stop playing cards, you may reorder them all and return them to the top of the deck.If you happen to draw a Change of Plans Task, set aside the other cards you’ve already drawn and shuffle the Task Discard pile into the Task Deck. Continue drawing as though you hadn’t drawn the Change of Plans card, then shuffle the Change of Plans back into the deck. That’s not quite what the rules say, but it works well enough.
  • Travel: You may discard a card with Movement Icons on it to gain that many movement points for the turn. Whenever you move to an adjacent space on your turn, you spend one of your available Movement Points. You do not have to spend them all at once (and you don’t have to spend all of them), but any unspent points are lost at the end of your turn.
  • Secure: You may discard a card with Fortification Icons on it to add Fortification Tokens to the space you’re on or any adjacent space, one at a time (meaning they can be placed on different spaces). You cannot place them on rivers or fountains, and they cannot be moved once they’re placed (unless otherwise stated). Like movement, you do not have to spend them all at once (and you don’t have to spend all of them), but any unspent tokens are lost at the end of your turn.
  • Scheme: You may discard a card to perform the text on the card. If it has immediate effects, resolve them before continuing; if it has ongoing effects, keep it in front of you while those effects are ongoing, only discarding the card once it ends.

Gameplay 2

Once you’ve performed all of your actions, draw cards to end your turn:

  • 1 player: Draw 4 cards.
  • 2 players: Draw 2 cards.
  • 3 players: Draw 2 cards if you’re currently the Start Player; 1 otherwise.
  • 4 players: Draw 1 card.

Naturally, if the resource deck runs out of cards, shuffle the discard pile to form a new deck and keep drawing. If that’s also empty, then, well … tell your allies to play more cards.

Army Phase

Time for the fighting. This is where the two armies come together and sort out their differences. The major things to know:

  • On a Task Card, a specific group of soldiers will be designated. The game refers to them as the active group. If there are no more soldiers of that group type, remove that card from the game and flip a new Task Card.
  • Just as some solid advice from the rules, flip and read both armies’ Ploy and Task Cards before executing either one.

Gameplay 4

The armies will resolve their Task Cards as dictated by their Ploy; it provides a speed (usually) at which these actions resolve. Fast happens before Normal happens before Slow, and Move happens before Cover happens before Strike, in case you were looking to distinguish between those. The same orders with the same speed happen simultaneously, if possible. Here’s how those orders break down:

  • Move: Units will attempt to move a space closer to the enemy in the direction of their direction marker. Units cannot move into the same space as enemy units, and if this movement would put them no closer to the enemy, they do not move. Fun thing is that if you’re sharing a space with a moving unit, you can move with it for free. What fun!
  • Cover: Each unit in the active group covering gains an effective +2 Defense.
  • Strike: Here’s the complicated one. This one has the active group attack any unit (your adventurers don’t count) within its range (the target icon on its unit card). It prioritizes the closest enemy (straight ahead, then scan in a clockwise circle), then the most damaged enemy, then the lowest ranked (fewest stars) enemy. If you still can’t pick one in particular, roll the die and assign it randomly.When you attack, you deal damage, usually, equal to the bow / sword icon on the unit’s card. This may be boosted by shatter, which is given to enemies standing on river spaces. It may be reduced by cliffs and towers that have a defense point on them, as well as Fortification Tokens you’ve placed previously. Since these effects reduce incoming damage, if a unit is being attacked by multiple other units, add the attacks together and treat them as one attack. Each shatter increases damage by 1, each defense decreases damage by 1. For each point of damage that they still have unresolved, the unit gets a pink Damage Token placed next to them. If that ever exceeds its health, it is defeated and removed from the game. Decrease its’ side’s motivation by 1.If you happen to accidentally defeat the last unit or the last leader of a side, their motivation immediately drops to 0. You lose, and so do they. Try to avoid that outcome.
  • Revoked. Some Ploy Cards just say Revoked on them. When this happens, the side is worn out. Reduce its motivation by 1 and do nothing else. That can be helpful or disastrous, if you planned for it (or forgot to).

Once the armies have completed their actions, move on to the Status Phase.

Gameplay 3

Status Phase

Here’s where you check for game completion. As you progress through the game, I assume there will be additional game end criteria, but currently it’s just this:

  • You win if both sides have 2 or 1 Motivation at the end of a round.
  • You lose if at least one side has 0 Motivation at the end of a round.

Continue until the game ends!

Player Count Differences

There aren’t really major ones, which is nice; it just distributes more of the cards throughout players’ hands, as of the first scenario. It’s totally possible that eventually this will no longer be the case, which is kind of interesting, but who knows! I certainly don’t. It’s even super fun solo, which is nice, but it’s definitely harder to get places. Probably a slight preference for it at two? But it’s very slight; I’ve been considering a solo campaign with my … copious free time, but I keep not doing it because I don’t actually ever have any free time.

Strategy

  • Manipulate the decks. You’re not just going to need to set it up to Revoked every so often; you’re going to want to have units waste Cover actions, units Strike from out of range, and units accidentally buff themselves, only to Move. These armies need to be haphazard as all hell, and with your influence they certainly will be. Similar to other cooperative games, you don’t want these armies to be allowed to act randomly (unless it doesn’t matter). Know what’s available, and then make sure you spend some time limiting the negative possibilities. You may even want to avoid the Revoked if they’re already at low Motivation; don’t risk them hitting 0 and surrendering!
  • Watch for the ebb and flow of the attacks. If a set of units has Striked a lot, it means they probably won’t for a bit; it’s either time to eliminate them or time to pull them back, depending on what you need. Remember how many cards of each type are in the decks. You’ll also need to sort of ebb and flow so that you’re not letting one side overwhelm the other; that’s a bad mistake to make this early on in the game.
  • There are many easy ways to get units into bad locations. A lot of the best thing you can do is use cards that allow you to move your Companion Unit with you. That fortified archer? Now in the river, taking shatter damage. The leader, charging to the forefront? Now even further back, completely out of the action.
  • Don’t forget about terrain bonuses / penalties. Again, the fortified tower also provides motivation as long as there’s a unit in it. Taking that unit out and then setting them up to be defeated just doubles the motivation penalty that that side takes. That’s sometimes really good and sometimes absolutely terrible. It’s important to know which is which. Also, some units can gain stealth, which means they can only be attacked from adjacent spaces. That can sometimes throw you off; watch out for that.
  • Honestly, just keep the leader out of the fight. You really cannot risk getting them killed; I don’t even know how that affects the game, but I’m positive you’re not getting off scot-free if you do that.
  • Remember that some units do not move. That’s a problem you can fix yourself, if you’re feeling enterprising, but they might just not have Move Task Cards. If that’s the case, they’re not budging. Account for that in your planning and strategy, otherwise you’re in for a nasty surprise.

Pros, Mehs, and Cons

Pros

  • The first scenario is a good warmup. I’ve played a bit further and it’s a good way to introduce you to the concepts of the game while you’re still ramping up on how to play. I really like it and I would recommend it to others. I think Fog of Love still has my vote for best tutorial of all the games I’ve played, but this is a solid introduction. I’ve played it a few times to get a general feel for the mechanics, as well, and I think it’s a great way to get started.
  • I really like the Daimyria world. It’s got nice worldbuilding and I appreciate how it hooks into the Dale of Merchants games. If you’re interested in their backstory at all, this is definitely worth playing, especially with the Dale of Merchants collection coming up soon.
  • The mini sculpts are really nice. Especially the flying macaws. The whole thing looks incredible and makes me wish I were actually good at things so that I could paint them.
  • Solid cooperative play. Each player has some control over what they can do on their turn (because many actions require you to share a space with another army) and other players can chip in on certain actions. It’s got some vulnerability to one player attempting to dominate, but if that starts to happen, just make a firm “no revealing or discussing cards in hand” rule, like for Pandemic. That usually solves the problem.
  • Really great art. Sami is a super talented artist, and the work he put into making the game vibrant and colorful pretty much shows everywhere. It’s a really good-looking game.
  • The campaign decks are really well-organized to avoid spoilers. The major issue I had with The Rise of Queensdale was that all the spoilers were just on one big page that you had to try and avoid when you were looking for something specific; this has sealed boxes, sealed envelopes, and wrapped decks so that you can’t really sneak a look at anything; it’s possible to figure out some things (there are some minis you can see in my photos that aren’t used in the first scenario), but the actual details are pretty well-hidden.

Mehs

  • Change of Plans with small decks can be kind of annoying. The best fix is just to shuffle the deck, draw the new cards you need, and then shuffle Change of Plans back in. It’s a bit quicker than drawing Change of Plans every time because you’re bad at shuffling, like me.
  • It’s a bit weird, conceptually, that your goal is just to help the armies kill each other just the right amount. I get that you kind of need that from a gameplay perspective, but that’s definitely given me pause a few times while I’m playing. Oh well.
  • The difference between the gear bottom and the star bottom is kinda nuanced. There’s not much that can be done now but having a midpoint between the gear and the circle (which is what I think the star was trying to do, but the edges are a bit too pronounced) might alleviate some of that confusion. I’ve played with people who have struggled a lot with trying to differentiate between those two, which is a problem when they’re also the people in charge of setting up the game. Whoops.

Cons

  • Tracking damage is kind of clunky. Having to place the tokens next to the unit adds lot of visual clutter to the board, especially as units start to converge on multiple spaces. That said, I think this might be the best way to do it without investing in a ton of extra tracking components that would make the game more unwieldy.

Overall: 8.75 / 10

In Progress

Overall, I’m really excited about Dawn of Peacemakers! I’ve really liked what I’ve played of it, so far, and I’m looking forward to seeing how the story continues. For players hitting it for the first time, you’ll find some hybrid of a wargame and a resource management game; you’re managing both sides of the conflict and making sure that they gradually wear each other down. The game does a good job of helping you understand (sometimes in a trial-by-fire sense) that if you allow the pendulum to swing too heavily in one direction, you’ll end up letting a leader die or one side get routed. There’s an interesting idea of balance that the game tries to achieve, and I think it does a pretty good job leading players towards it. Plus, it’s got fantastic art, an interesting story (from what I’ve been able to glean of it so far) and a neat gradually-unlockable campaign mode. If you’re looking for a new cooperative campaign and you want to try something a bit different than the usual or you’re a huge fan of the Dale of Merchants series and you want to dig in a bit deeper as far as the lore is concerned, I’d say that Dawn of Peacemakers is certainly worth checking out! I’ve really had a lot of fun with it and I’m looking forward to having time to complete the entire campaign, eventually, probably, hopefully.


If you enjoyed this review and would like to support What’s Eric Playing? in the future, please check out my Patreon. Thanks for reading!

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s